Surfshark vs Proton VPN: Which VPN fits your needs?

Choosing the right VPN service is crucial for individuals and businesses seeking to protect their online privacy, secure their data, and access content globally in today’s digitally connected world. Compared to relying solely on traditional security measures, VPNs offer enhanced privacy, encrypted connections, and the ability to bypass geo-restrictions. But which VPN service should you choose: Surfshark or Proton VPN?

This article compares Surfshark vs. Proton VPN, two leading VPN providers that help you safeguard your online activities, maintain anonymity, and access restricted content. By examining their key differences, features, and specific use cases, you’ll have a clear understanding of which VPN service best suits your privacy needs and browsing habits by the end of this comparison.

When it comes to IT security software and VPN services, Surfshark and Proton VPN stand out as two of the most prominent players, each offering robust tools to help individuals and businesses secure their online activities and maintain privacy. The decision between Surfshark vs. Proton VPN can be a challenging one, given their diverse and comprehensive feature sets.

To assist you in making an informed choice for your privacy and security needs, we’ve created a comparative table that highlights the key attributes of each VPN service. Each feature is evaluated with a star rating and accompanied by detailed commentary, providing you with a thorough assessment of what Surfshark and Proton VPN offer. This resource is designed to guide you through the Surfshark vs. Proton VPN landscape, enabling you to choose the VPN service that best aligns with your online security goals and requirements.

Surfshark and Proton VPN are two leading VPN services designed to help users secure their online activities and protect their privacy. While both serve the essential purpose of encrypting internet traffic and safeguarding personal data, several key differences set them apart, primarily in their approach, features, and target audiences.

The most notable difference lies in their core functionalities and focus areas. Surfshark is known for its user-friendly interface, affordability, and extensive feature set, making it an attractive choice for users looking for a comprehensive yet budget-friendly VPN. It offers unlimited simultaneous connections, robust security features, and access to over 3,200 servers in 100+ countries, making it ideal for families or small businesses that need to secure multiple devices at once. Surfshark is also particularly strong in unblocking streaming services like Netflix and Disney+, providing a seamless experience for users who prioritize accessing geo-restricted content.

On the other hand, Proton VPN stands out for its strong emphasis on privacy and security. Developed by the creators of ProtonMail, it offers a high level of encryption, a strict no-logs policy, and advanced security features like Secure Core, which routes traffic through multiple servers in privacy-friendly countries. Proton VPN is particularly well-suited for privacy-conscious users, journalists, or activists who need the highest level of anonymity and data protection. While Proton VPN's server network is smaller, with around 3,000 servers in 70+ countries, it prioritizes quality and security over quantity.

Another key difference is in their pricing models. Surfshark offers a highly competitive pricing structure with a range of subscription plans, often including generous discounts for long-term commitments. Proton VPN offers a free tier with limited features, alongside tiered paid plans that cater to users who require enhanced security features.

Surfshark is best for users seeking a feature-rich, affordable VPN with strong streaming capabilities, while Proton VPN excels for those who prioritize privacy and security above all else.

• Unlimited simultaneous connections: Surfshark allows unlimited devices to be connected to the VPN simultaneously under one subscription, making it ideal for families or small businesses with multiple devices.
• Affordable pricing: Surfshark is known for its competitive pricing, especially with long-term plans. It offers a lot of value for money considering the extensive feature set it provides.
• Strong security features: Surfshark offers robust security features, including AES-256 encryption, a kill switch, CleanWeb (ad and malware blocker), and MultiHop (double VPN). These features ensure high levels of security and privacy.
• Great for streaming: Surfshark is excellent at unblocking geo-restricted content on popular streaming services like Netflix, Disney+, and Amazon Prime Video, providing access to content from different regions.
• User-friendly interface: The Surfshark app is intuitive and easy to use, making it accessible for both VPN beginners and experienced users. The setup process is straightforward across all devices and platforms.

• Inconsistent speeds: While Surfshark generally offers good speeds, some users may experience inconsistent speeds on certain servers, which can affect streaming or gaming performance.
• Limited server network compared to competitors: Surfshark has a smaller server network (3,200+ servers) compared to some competitors, which may lead to occasional server congestion or limited server options in less common locations.
• No dedicated IP option: Surfshark does not offer a dedicated IP option, which might be a drawback for users who require a consistent IP address for certain services or activities.
• Mixed customer support experience: While Surfshark offers 24/7 customer support, some users have reported inconsistent experiences with response times and the effectiveness of the support provided.
• Recent entry to the market: Surfshark is relatively new compared to some long-established VPN providers. While it has gained a good reputation, some users may prefer a VPN with a longer track record.

• Strong emphasis on privacy: Proton VPN is developed by the creators of ProtonMail, with a strong focus on privacy and security. It offers a strict no-logs policy, meaning your online activities are not tracked or stored.
• Advanced security features: Proton VPN provides advanced security features such as Secure Core, which routes traffic through multiple servers in privacy-friendly countries, and AES-256 encryption. It also supports Perfect Forward Secrecy, ensuring that even if an encryption key is compromised, it cannot be used to decrypt past communications.
• Free tier available: Proton VPN offers a free plan with no data limits, which is rare among VPN providers. This free tier includes access to servers in three countries and provides a basic level of security for users on a budget.
• Open source and audited: Proton VPN’s apps are open-source and have undergone independent security audits. This transparency builds trust with users who value knowing exactly how the software functions and ensuring there are no hidden vulnerabilities.
• Excellent for high privacy needs: Proton VPN is an excellent choice for users who require high levels of privacy, such as journalists, activists, or those living in countries with strict censorship. The Secure Core feature and strong encryption make it a top choice for protecting sensitive data.

• Limited server network: Proton VPN has a smaller server network compared to some competitors, with around 3,000 servers in 70+ countries. This can lead to limited server options and possibly slower connection speeds due to server congestion.
• Higher pricing for premium plans: Proton VPN’s premium plans are priced higher than many competitors, particularly if you require access to all features and the full range of servers. This might be a drawback for users looking for a budget-friendly option.
• No SmartDNS or streaming features: Proton VPN does not offer SmartDNS or dedicated streaming features, which can make it less effective at unblocking certain geo-restricted content on platforms like Netflix or Hulu.
• Slower connection speeds: While Proton VPN prioritizes privacy, this focus can sometimes result in slower connection speeds, especially when using Secure Core servers or when connected to distant servers.
• Limited simultaneous connections: Proton VPN limits the number of simultaneous connections depending on the plan, with the basic paid plan allowing only two connections. This can be restrictive for users with multiple devices or larger households.

Surfshark and Proton VPN are both strong contenders in the VPN market, each catering to different user needs. Surfshark stands out for its affordability, user-friendly interface, and ability to unblock streaming services, making it ideal for casual users and families needing multiple connections. 

In contrast, Proton VPN is designed for privacy-conscious users, offering advanced security features like Secure Core and a strict no-logs policy, making it a preferred choice for those who prioritize anonymity. While Surfshark excels in value and ease of use, Proton VPN focuses on delivering high-level security and privacy.

Determining whether Surfshark is better than Proton VPN depends on your priorities. Surfshark excels in affordability and ease of use, making it an attractive option for users seeking budget-friendly, straightforward VPN services with excellent streaming capabilities. It offers features that cater to everyday needs and supports unlimited device connections. 

Conversely, Proton VPN is superior in delivering advanced privacy features and top-notch security, such as Secure Core, which provides enhanced anonymity for users in high-risk environments. It is ideal for those who place a premium on privacy and security over cost. Surfshark suits general use, while Proton VPN is tailored for privacy-focused individuals.

Surfshark is best used for individuals and families looking for a cost-effective, user-friendly VPN that provides robust online security and privacy. It excels at unblocking geo-restricted content, making it a popular choice for streaming services like Netflix, Disney+, and Amazon Prime Video. 

With unlimited simultaneous connections, Surfshark is ideal for securing multiple devices at once, offering strong protection across desktops, smartphones, tablets, and more. Additionally, its clean interface and powerful security features, including ad-blocking and malware protection, make Surfshark an excellent choice for those who want a hassle-free, comprehensive VPN solution.

Surfshark can replace Proton VPN for users who prioritize ease of use, affordability, and the ability to connect multiple devices simultaneously. It offers strong security features, effective geo-unblocking for streaming, and a competitive pricing structure, making it a solid alternative for general VPN needs. 

However, Proton VPN excels in providing advanced privacy features and security, particularly for users who require high levels of anonymity and protection, such as activists or journalists. While Surfshark is a versatile and user-friendly option, it may not fully replace Proton VPN for those who need the utmost in privacy and security measures.

Yes, Surfshark is generally cheaper than Proton VPN, particularly when you consider long-term subscription plans. Surfshark’s pricing is competitive, with substantial discounts on multi-year plans, making it one of the more affordable VPN options on the market. It also provides unlimited device connections under a single subscription, adding to its value. 

Proton VPN, while offering a free tier, has higher prices for its premium plans, especially those with advanced security features and access to its full server network. For budget-conscious users who need a cost-effective VPN solution, Surfshark typically offers better overall pricing compared to Proton VPN.

While Surfshark is a popular and highly regarded VPN service, there are alternative options to Surfshark like NordVPN, ExpressVPN, and CyberGhost that are also widely used for online privacy and security. The best choice depends on your specific needs and preferences.

For users seeking top-tier security features and a vast server network, NordVPN might offer an advantage with its advanced encryption, Double VPN, and a broader range of servers. ExpressVPN, on the other hand, excels in providing consistently fast speeds and a reputation for reliability, making it ideal for those prioritizing performance and global access. Choosing the right VPN depends on aligning its features with your privacy requirements, usage patterns, and the level of security you demand.

Proton VPN and Surfshark are both strong VPN services, but they cater to different priorities. Proton VPN is focused on delivering top-tier privacy and security, with features like Secure Core and a strict no-logs policy, making it ideal for users who need enhanced anonymity. It also offers open-source applications and independent audits for added transparency. 

Surfshark, however, is more user-friendly and budget-conscious, offering unlimited device connections, robust security, and excellent streaming capabilities at a lower cost. While Proton VPN excels in privacy, Surfshark provides a more accessible and versatile option for everyday users.

Whether Proton VPN is better than Surfshark largely depends on your specific needs. Proton VPN is superior for those who prioritize maximum privacy and advanced security features, thanks to its Secure Core architecture and strict no-logs policy. Its open-source applications and regular independent audits provide additional transparency for users concerned about data protection. 

On the other hand, Surfshark excels in providing a user-friendly experience and affordability, making it ideal for users seeking a cost-effective solution that supports unlimited device connections and excels in unblocking streaming services. For privacy-focused individuals, Proton VPN may be preferable, while Surfshark offers broader appeal for general use.

Proton VPN is best used for individuals and organizations that prioritize strong privacy and security in their online activities. Developed by the team behind ProtonMail, it is designed to protect sensitive information and ensure anonymity, making it ideal for journalists, activists, and anyone in need of robust data protection. 

Its Secure Core feature, which routes traffic through multiple privacy-friendly countries, offers an additional layer of security against surveillance. Proton VPN is also well-suited for users in restrictive environments, providing reliable access to censored content while maintaining a strict no-logs policy to safeguard user privacy.

Proton VPN can replace Surfshark for users who prioritize privacy and security above all else. It offers advanced features like Secure Core, strong encryption, and a strict no-logs policy, making it an excellent choice for those needing high levels of anonymity and data protection. 

However, while Proton VPN excels in privacy, it may not fully match Surfshark's strengths in affordability, ease of use, and streaming capabilities. Surfshark's unlimited device connections and user-friendly interface make it more suitable for users seeking a versatile, cost-effective VPN solution.

Proton VPN is generally more expensive than Surfshark, especially when comparing premium plans. While Proton VPN offers a free tier with limited features, its paid plans are priced higher due to the advanced privacy features and security protocols it provides, such as Secure Core and its strong no-logs policy. 

Surfshark, on the other hand, is known for its affordability, offering more competitive pricing with significant discounts on long-term subscriptions. Additionally, Surfshark includes unlimited device connections, further enhancing its value. For budget-conscious users, Surfshark typically presents a more cost-effective option compared to Proton VPN's premium pricing structure.

Proton VPN is a strong choice for users who prioritize privacy and security, but there are several alternatives to Proton VPN that offer features worth considering.

NordVPN stands out with its extensive server network and advanced security options like Double VPN and Onion Over VPN, making it ideal for users who need a balance of privacy and performance. ExpressVPN offers superior speed and reliability, particularly for streaming and global access, making it a strong contender for those who prioritize performance. Mullvad, known for its commitment to anonymity, offers a unique payment model and high privacy standards. The choice between these VPN services depends on your specific privacy needs, performance expectations, and feature preferences.

When considering the user-friendliness of a VPN service, Surfshark shines over Proton VPN, especially for everyday users who prioritize simplicity and ease of use. Surfshark’s clean and intuitive interface allows users to set up and configure their VPN with minimal effort, making it accessible even to those without technical expertise. For instance, its streamlined navigation and one-click connect feature ensure that you can get online securely with just a single tap, without delving into complex settings. 

In contrast, Proton VPN, while highly secure, can feel overwhelming due to its more advanced settings and configurations, which may require a learning curve. Surfshark’s focus on simplicity makes it a superior choice for users who want a hassle-free VPN experience.

When evaluating integration possibilities, Surfshark clearly outperforms Proton VPN. Surfshark boasts extensive compatibility with a broad range of devices and platforms, securing your digital presence not just on computers but also on mobile devices, smart TVs, and even gaming consoles. For example, Surfshark seamlessly integrates with entertainment platforms like Amazon Fire TV and various router models, allowing for comprehensive protection throughout your home. 

In contrast, while Proton VPN does support a range of devices, its integration options are more limited and can be somewhat complex to configure. For users seeking effortless integration across diverse devices and platforms, Surfshark is the superior choice.

While both Surfshark and Proton VPN offer robust security features, Surfshark stands out with its integrated antivirus protection. Proton VPN relies on strong encryption and a strict no-logs policy to secure your data, focusing solely on VPN functionalities without incorporating additional malware protection. 

In contrast, Surfshark goes a step further by including an antivirus feature in its service, offering real-time protection against malware, ransomware, and other online threats. For instance, Surfshark’s antivirus actively scans for potential threats and provides alerts if harmful files are detected, adding an extra layer of security that Proton VPN does not offer. If comprehensive protection is a priority, Surfshark’s all-in-one approach makes it a more robust choice.

Both Surfshark and Proton VPN offer robust VPN services with geographical versatility, but Proton VPN has a slight edge with its more extensive global server network. Proton VPN boasts servers in over 50 countries, providing a broader range of locations to bypass geo-restrictions and access international content. This expansive network can result in faster and more reliable connections, enhancing the overall browsing experience. 

For example, Proton VPN’s wide server coverage allows users to easily connect to servers in less common locations, ensuring smoother access to region-specific content. While Surfshark also offers a substantial network, Proton VPN’s greater global reach gives it a notable advantage in terms of geographical flexibility.

Surfshark and Proton VPN both provide secure and encrypted internet access, but Proton VPN distinguishes itself with its unique split tunneling feature. This functionality allows users to direct specific applications or services through the VPN while permitting others to connect directly to the internet. 

For instance, you can choose to route your web browser through the VPN for privacy while allowing a local app, like a video streaming service, to bypass it for faster performance. Surfshark, although comprehensive in its VPN services, does not offer split tunneling, making Proton VPN a more flexible choice for users needing customized connection options.

When it comes to maintaining user privacy, both Surfshark and Proton VPN excel, each offering distinct features to ensure confidentiality. Surfshark provides unique tools like Alternative ID, which masks your online identity, and Privacy Search, a search engine that doesn't track or store your queries. These features enhance anonymity and prevent data collection. 

Similarly, Proton VPN upholds a rigorous no-logs policy, ensuring that none of your online activities are tracked, stored, or shared. Both services prioritize user privacy and offer strong protections, making them equally commendable for users seeking robust confidentiality in their online interactions.

Surfshark and Proton VPN both emphasize user privacy, but Surfshark offers a unique advantage with its data breach alerts feature. This proactive security tool notifies you if your personal information appears in any known data breaches, enabling you to take immediate action to protect your accounts. For example, if your email or password is compromised, Surfshark’s alerts allow you to update your credentials promptly. 

Proton VPN, while strong in privacy with its encryption and no-logs policy, does not provide a similar breach alert system. This additional layer of proactive security makes Surfshark a superior choice for users seeking enhanced protection against potential data leaks.